WHAT'S IN SEASON – Dive into the cool and briny waters of the Italian coast and discover sea-inspired favorites at 10% off online. Shop now!

A Farm-Fresh Thanksgiving

A Farm-Fresh Thanksgiving

This November, get a jump on your Thanksgiving to-do list: pre-order an all-natural, humanely-raised turkey from our regional farms, then plan the rest of your menu with our housemade stuffing, sides, and more!


Pre-order one of our farm-fresh turkeys before November 19 by visiting or calling our butcher counter: 212.897.2895 ext. 537.

Then, complete your Thanksgiving menu with our selection of Italian condiments, housemade sides (think: sweet sausage turkey giblets!), and seasonal beers.


At Eataly, we are proud to offer Thanksgiving turkeys that have been raised exclusively for us. We carefully sourced our birds from just two small-scale farms that follow the Eataly philosophy of good, clean, and fair. Every step taken ensures that the finished product on your Thanksgiving table is of the utmost quality and fullest flavor.


8-20 pound turkeys; $5.80 per pound

Bell & Evans is a family-run company that has been dedicated to raising quality birds since 1894. Raised without antibiotics and free-range on Jaindl Farms in Pennsylvania Dutch Country, their turkeys are truly one of a kind. With 20% more breast meat than other brands, they also boast 55% less fat and 25% fewer calories. Your turkey will certainly be the showcase of the Thanksgiving meal.


8-20 pound pasture-raised turkeys; $6.80 per pound

As its name implies, Arcadian Pastures is an idyllic farm located in Sloansville in upstate New York. The family-run operation raises non-GMO heritage turkeys with the belief that animals raised outdoors, free to roam high-quality pastures, with no antibiotics or added hormones, and treated with respect will produce the most nutritionally-dense and best-tasting meats.


10-16 pound heritage turkeys; $7.80/pound

Cascun Farms is located on 125 acres of rolling pasture in the rural farming community of Greene in upstate New York. Cascun Farms is a family-run business that strives to raise only the highest quality heritage red bronze non-GMO turkeys on free range pastures without using antibiotics or hormones.

Stuffing thanksgiving

After you pre-order your bird, check out our delicious recipes for roast turkey and mushroom-sausage stuffing!